Starting a Conversation?
Election night, I rushed home from my very late vote, hurriedly ate, and settled in for an evening of election coverage. I toggled back and forth among (in alphabetical order) CNN, C-SPAN, Fox, and MSNBC because I like to hear multiple points of view. I visited political website with various perspectives. Then, while running errands Wednesday, I listened to some talk radio.
Tuesday and Wednesday, I seemed to find general agreement on the facts: who won where, what the exit polls revealed, and even approximately when each network believed it had enough information to project winners. I say "seemed" because I wasn't conducting a scientific survey.
The commentary, however, was nothing short of bizarre. From Fox News and talk radio, I heard Obama was elected by a coalition of Socialists who want free healthcare and cell phones, women who voted with their vaginas, Black Panthers who stuffed ballot boxes in Philadelphia, and shady types who want to drive America over the "Fiscal Cliff."
From MSNBC and other sources, I learned that Romney's supporters were white racists, angry men who used their power to keep minorities away from the polls, theocrats who want to strip rights from women and gay people, and greedy billionaires who want to push Grandma off a cliff even while she tries to take her last bite of cat food.
No wonder pundits say we're polarized!
Because I happen to have a lot of liberal friends, a lot of conservative friends, and a lot of friends whose political leanings are obscure to me, I compared what I was told about voters and what I know about real people.
I couldn't think of a single friend who is demanding that free cell phone, who sees herself as a walking vagina, or who wants to see our republic and our economy fail. Nor could I name anyone who votes solely based on race, wants to set up the Christian version of sharia, or really thinks it's about danged time for old people to just die and get off the public teat.
Oh, I'm sure people who fit those unflattering descriptions are out there, and I heard plenty of anecdotes to remind me they exist. No doubt, somewhere in America, someone voted illegally or more than once, and even one instance is too many. I also heard credibly of at least one 2008 Obama voter being told not to "renig" in 2012. That's pretty disgusting.
What disturbed me most, however, is that conservatives get their descriptions and definitions of liberals from other conservatives, sometimes ultra-conservatives who are paid very well for keeping their audiences riled up. Likewise, many liberals know what they believe they know about conservatives because other liberals with agendas that aren't driven by truth tell them how conservatives think.
Not only is this situation wrong, but it is also very dangerous. It flunks a test of basic logic and fairness. Since when did conservatives become the leading experts on liberals or vice versa? Shouldn't people be allowed to define their own causes and submit them for everyone's consideration?
Our nation has two large political parties that reliably turn out tens of millions of voters every time we elect a President. I don't think they're really talking with each other, though. I know the Republicans don't say what I want to hear, and then when I fail to support their candidates, they define Democrats in ways that don't describe me. And I have enough conservative friends that I don't think the Democratic ads reach out to or the liberal election post-mortems accurately characterize them.
My one-on-one conversations since the election have often included an arduous effort to peel back media-fed stereotypes. Sadly, that effort has sometimes failed. People who get 90% of their news from people of their own political persuasion too often think they know what they don't.
I'm not suggesting that my conservative friends turn on Rachel Maddow or that my liberal ones become Rush Limbaugh listeners. What I do strongly urge my conservative friends who want to know what motivates liberals do is ask a liberal. There are millions of us. And if my liberal friends want to know what conservatives really think, ask a conservative. They, too, abound
Mostly, though, I encourage conservatives to ask themselves whether they even have any liberal friends, and I challenge liberals to do likewise. If the answer is "No," you must consider at least the possibility that you live in an echo chamber. You are depriving yourself of the opportunity to meet and get to know some very fine people who share your patriotism, love of freedom, and devotion to liberty.
They just have different ideas about how to get there, and that difference is a strength, not a weakness, of our country.
It's as American as apple pie, a chicken chimichanga, a beef stir fry, and a good plate of greens.
